Skip to content
Radical Economics
Go back

Capitalism = free markets + extraction

We talk about capitalism a lot. But what is it? You might hear some or all of the following, depending on who you listen to:

I think all of these things are true to some extent, but there are different ideas getting tangled up here, and I’d like to disentangle them.

Capitalism: A definition

OK, let’s try a simple definition:

Capitalism=Free markets+Extraction\text{Capitalism} = \text{Free markets} + \text{Extraction}

By splitting the two, we can gain some clarity, and think about which we’d want to keep, and which discard, if we were to move away from capitalism. But it does kick the can down the road, rather, because now we need to define ‘Free markets’ and ‘Extraction’…

Free markets

Free markets are pretty much what it says on the tin. People are free to buy and sell goods and services as they choose, at a price they mutually agree on, in a competitive way. The vision is that the market ‘decides’1 a fair price and the right amount of supply based on the laws of supply and demand. If lots of people want something, the price goes up and it’s more attractive for more suppliers to enter the market. If they don’t, the suppliers find themselves competing on price and some of them will go bust or do something else. Competition can seem inefficient, and sometimes brutal, but it seems to work, at least on a small-to-medium scale.

In reality, though, free markets aren’t always as pure as their radical libertarian fans would hold them up to be. It’s possible for one supplier, or a cartel of cooperating suppliers, to achieve a monopoly position, removing all competition by fair means or foul, and ‘gouge’ customers with high prices or poor quality. It may be that some suppliers gain an advantage by forcing their staff to work for low pay or in bad conditions, or by producing goods or services that are unsafe. This is why, in practice, we have a regulated market, which tries to curb the excesses while retaining the core freedoms. It’s a fine line to walk, and a subject of legitimate debate.

Generally, though, I – and I think most pragmatic people – recognise that tempered free markets are a good thing, not least because history shows us what happens when they are suppressed.

Planned economies

The opposite of a free market economy is a ‘planned economy’ where some central body decides how many of something should be produced, by whom, and what they should sell for. In theory, this benevolent, all-seeing commander can work out exactly how much of what is needed where, and Make It So.

In reality, though, I’m not sure it has ever worked. Apart from denying people control over their lives, it doesn’t react quickly enough, suppresses innovation and is prone to corruption.

The obvious lessons from history are the Soviet era in the USSR (more tractors!)2 and the disastrous attempts to control agriculture in China3 and Cambodia.4 But there are examples much closer to home, as we’ll see.

Extraction

‘Extraction’ is a relatively neutral term for the processes in our economy which move wealth from the majority of ordinary people ‘upwards’5 to a richer minority. If you’re on the winning side, you might call it ‘investment’ or ‘passive income’. If you’re on the losing side, you might say ‘rentierism’ or ‘unearned income’.

The three main processes at work doing this are rent, interest and profit. I have a separate post laying all this out in detail, but the net effect of all three is the same. People who are already rich get richer, at the expense of the relatively poor. This compounds, so it keeps getting worse, and you get the extremes of inequality we are now seeing.

I created a simple visual simulation of this, to see what happens when money flows from poorer to richer, along with some random fair trading, every time they interact:

Everyone starts off equal, but over time you’ll see a few big green blobs (the rich) have taken all the value, leaving lots of small orange and red ones (the poor), who are only saved from death by an assumed basic welfare system. Sound familiar?

You can adjust all the parameters and play to your heart’s content on the full simulation page.

This extraction of value is so completely embedded in our everyday lives that it’s very difficult to imagine a non-extractive economy, but let’s try. First we need a name for it.

Generation

Because extraction is so much the ‘norm’ in our economy, it’s hard to even find a positive name for its absence. I’m going to go with ‘generation’ or ‘generative’, which has some pedigree6 and suggests a virtuous cycle rather than a vicious one.

For the same reason, it’s hard to point to good examples of a whole economy, although there are plenty of individual businesses and community enterprises that fit the bill. The main theme of this blog will be to explore what this looks like, and how we can get there.

Put simply, a generative economy is one where money circulates to exchange goods and services and can be stored for a future purchase or retirement, but without the mechanisms of rent, interest and profit which extract it from the poor to give to the rich.

Just for comparison, here’s the same simulation with the extraction turned off. It’s much less dramatic, even boring7 – but there is still some inequality even with random fair trade. That’s an interesting result I’ll return to in a later post.

Four economies

Now we have two independent ways of describing an economy, each with two options, which gives us four combinations:

ExtractiveGenerative
Free marketThe neoliberal capitalism we know and love/hateA fair and free economy – our target
Planned economyThe reality of communism
State over-reach in modern economies
The ideal of state communism

It should be clear from this that where I want to go – and hope to persuade you to go too – is a horizontal move from extractive free market to generative free market, not a vertical move to increased planning and centralised control. The key takeaway from this post is that these are independent choices!

Let’s look at each of these combinations individually:

Extractive free market

There are these two young fish swimming along, and they happen to meet an older fish swimming the other way, who nods at them and says, “Morning, boys, how’s the water?” And the two young fish swim on for a bit, and then eventually one of them looks over at the other and goes, “What the hell is water?”

David Foster Wallace8

Like the fish in water, when your whole life is lived within a system, it’s hard to see the system itself. We live within what is supposed to be a free market economy – the past 40+ years have had that as the Holy Grail, taken to extremes by neoliberals who believe the market can solve every problem, if only governments would get out of the way.

But this worldview is missing the water we are swimming in. We do have mostly free markets, at least at the small scale, but they operate within an extractive economy where wealth is systematically transferred from ordinary people to the already rich. This skews everything – to extend the fish analogy, the water is moving, and most of us spend our lives swimming against the current.

But beyond this general effect, the extreme concentration of wealth that it brings about breaks the free market model itself – it tends to promote monopolies, undue political influence, even corruption. Some of those who shout loudest about free markets are the biggest offenders.

Generative free market

So let’s imagine a town or village where everyone owns their own house and the income-earners in households own and work in small businesses. No-one is paying rent to a landlord. No-one is in debt to anyone outside the town, and terms are fair within it. Profits generated in the businesses are shared with the workers, reinvested or spent back in the community. People pay a local tax which supports those who cannot provide for themselves, pays the town’s schoolteacher and constable and keeps the streets clean, and a national tax for infrastructure, defence and other things that can’t be done locally.

Did such a place ever exist? Better historians than me can answer that, but my guess is that pioneer towns, disconnected from the pre-existing ownership structures of the ‘old country’, may have come close. But it doesn’t matter: we can imagine it anyway, and think about how such a model would scale to our modern society. That’s going to be a significant theme of this blog.

So as not to leave this as an abstract ideal, here are some of the structures and mechanisms we can look at:

I’ll focus on each of these as this blog develops.

Generative planned economy

The early proponents of small-scale communism like Shakespeare’s Gonzalo, Robert Owen, and then of course Marx and Engels themselves, had a vision of common ownership and money-free mutual support which was naturally ‘generative’, in that the mechanisms of extraction – rent, interest and profit – simply couldn’t exist.

The small-scale versions were ‘planned’ in the sense that a small business is planned. Small enough that information flows naturally, and you don’t need the market price signal as a proxy for how much of what should be produced. There may however have been an assumption that some wise and benevolent leader would make the big decisions – that’s certainly Shakespeare’s jibe about Gonzalo9.

In the Communist Manifesto, Marx & Engels don’t go into great detail, but the assumption of central planning is there. They want to centralise all instruments of production in the hands of the State, and go further in some specifics in the ten aims that follow:

…

  1. Centralisation of credit in the hands of the State, by means of a national bank with State capital and an exclusive monopoly.

  2. Centralisation of the means of communication and transport in the hands of the State.

  3. Extension of factories and instruments of production owned by the State; the bringing into cultivation of waste-lands, and the improvement of the soil generally in accordance with a common plan.

…

(my emphasis)

Whether this pure vision has ever actually been realised has been a subject of much late-night debate. If it did, it probably only worked for short periods of time and small groups of people. What did happen in large, supposedly ‘communist’ states like the former USSR and China was unfortunately much dirtier.

Extractive planned economy

Many people have written books and PhD theses on the problems of the USSR and China, but to me it comes down to three things:

  1. Human nature: Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.10 A large-scale centrally planned economy creates many opportunities for self-advancement, and it’s human nature to take them. Everyone wants to better their life, and that’s fine at a reasonable scale – it’s the extremes caused by compounded extraction that are the problem.

  2. The knowledge problem11: Large societies are simply too complex to centrally manage. Originally12 it was said that there were just too many variables to compute – these days with supercomputers and AI, that may be less the case. But the problem remains because of the limited flow of information – a central authority in London cannot reasonably know whether an influx of tourists in Cornwall has led to a shortage of pasties (oh, the horror!), or at least, not quickly enough to recalculate the entire economy to deal with it.

  3. Agency: People really don’t like being told what to do by central authorities, particularly if it appears to go against their own immediate interests because of some unknown and unknowable Grand Plan. If you want to force people, you need authoritarian mechanisms, which is why such societies have always ended up that way.

But is it right to call these economies ‘extractive’? The mechanisms of rent, interest and profit are supposedly designed out, yet there are still huge disparities of wealth and power in such societies. How do they arise?

As I just said about Power corrupts, in a centrally planned economy, there are always benefits to be had from positions of power or control of resources – the ability to award contracts, allocate housing, promote people… The Soviet nomenklatura were really good at this, and accrued the trappings of wealth – the best apartment, a dacha by the lake, first claim to medical treatment – denied to ordinary citizens.

To some extent these things compound and persist – the power of patronage and mutual back-scratching builds over time – but unlike capitalist extraction there’s no direct compounding or positive-feedback mechanism. It was only with the collapse of the USSR, when these power relations transmuted into real capitalist ownership, that we saw the extremes. You can see the same thing happening in supposedly communist (and still somewhat authoritarian) but actually capitalist economies like Vietnam. Extraction has a habit of re-appearing unless it’s carefully designed out.

There’s another way in which you can end up with an extractive planned economy, coming from the opposite direction: when governments in capitalist economies over-reach and start planning major aspects of the economy from the centre. In the UK we saw this during COVID when the government took central control of procuring personal protective equipment (PPE), leading to huge waste and profiteering by the ‘connected’. The defence industry is another chronic case of this, with legendary scales of waste and inefficiency13 combined with an unhealthily cosy relationship between government and near-monopoly suppliers. Whether it’s possible to manage defence in a more decentralised way is a discussion for another day.

In summary

We’ve seen that the term ‘capitalism’ gets confused with the concept of free markets, and that we could – and should – imagine a free market system without the built-in systemic unfairness of extraction through rent, interest and profit.

Conversely, we’ve seen that the opposite of free markets – central planning – has never really existed at scale in its pure, generative form, and in its real-world form tends to degrade into incredibly inefficient, corrupt and authoritarian regimes.

I hope I’ve shown through the ‘four economies’ that the choices are independent, and we should aim to move to a ‘generative’ free market economy, not a centrally planned one.

So we see the problem we need to solve. That’s what this blog is for.


Footnotes

  1. Really, the market is just the collective decisions of large numbers of (supposedly) informed and rational actors. ↩

  2. Stalin’s forced collectivisation of agriculture from 1929 produced the famine of 1932-33: most scholarly estimates put excess deaths in Ukraine alone at between 3.5 and 5 million, with millions more across the wider USSR, notably Kazakhstan. On the chronic shortages and misallocation of the planned economy itself, the classic account is János Kornai, Economics of Shortage (1980) and The Socialist System (1992). ↩

  3. The Great Leap Forward (1958-62) collectivised farming into people’s communes and set wildly unrealistic production targets; the resulting famine killed somewhere between 15 and 55 million people. Commonly cited figures are around 30 million; Yang Jisheng (Tombstone, 2008) estimates 36 million and Frank Dikötter (Mao’s Great Famine, 2010) at least 45 million. ↩

  4. The Khmer Rouge (1975-79) emptied the cities and imposed total agricultural collectivisation almost overnight. Ben Kiernan of Yale’s Genocide Studies Program estimates 1.7 million deaths from execution, starvation and overwork – about 21% of the 1975 population. ↩

  5. In the sense of moving up the wealth distribution scale. I’m not suggesting any kind of ‘looking up to your betters’. ↩

  6. In Owning Our Future (World of Books) Marjorie Kelly explores different models of ownership and talks about a ‘generative economy’ which recycles value into the community. ↩

  7. Maybe a ‘boring’ economy is another potential name, but it might be harder to sell! ↩

  8. Commencement address at Kenyon College, Ohio, 2005 ↩

  9. The Tempest, Act 2 Scene 1 – Gonzalo’s imagined commonwealth: “riches, poverty, / And use of service, none; contract, succession, / Bourn, bound of land, tilth, vineyard, none; / No use of metal, corn, or wine, or oil; / No occupation; all men idle, all”. Sebastian and Antonio’s heckle – “Yet he would be king on’t” – is the whole problem in six words. ↩

  10. Lord Acton, letter to Bishop Mandell Creighton, 5 April 1887. ↩

  11. Friedrich Hayek, The Use of Knowledge in Society, American Economic Review 35(4), September 1945. The problem, he argues, is not the volume of data but that the knowledge that matters – “the particular circumstances of time and place” – is dispersed among millions of people, constantly changing, and never available to any central authority in usable form. Prices are the mechanism that lets people act on knowledge they don’t individually have. ↩

  12. The earlier ‘too many equations’ version of the argument runs through Hayek’s edited volume Collectivist Economic Planning (1935), which collects Mises’s original 1920 calculation critique and Hayek’s own essays. Hayek’s 1945 paper is in part a reply to those who thought faster computation would settle the matter. ↩

  13. Two National Audit Office reports give the flavour. The Equipment Plan 2023 to 2033 (December 2023): the MoD’s own ten-year plan was £16.9bn over its £288.6bn budget, after the previous year’s plan had been assessed as affordable. The Ajax programme (March 2022): a £5.5bn contract for 589 armoured vehicles, four years late with no in-service date, 26 vehicles delivered against £3.2bn paid, and unresolved noise and vibration problems injuring the crews testing them. The NAO found the MoD “has not demonstrated value for money”. ↩


Share this post:

Next Post
Rent, interest and profit: unearned income