For unto every one that hath shall be given, and he shall have abundance: but from him that hath not shall be taken away even that which he hath. Matthew 25:29
Now I’m no biblical scholar1, but I would hope that Jesus was using this as an analogy for ‘talents’ of a more spiritual kind rather than monetary wealth, although the full Parable of the Talents reminds me of the entitlement of privilege and wealth that is all too familiar today.
Taken literally, though, this is obviously unfair, isn’t it? If you tried that in any small social group (playground, building site, pub…) you’d get at best complaints and at worst a trip to hospital. Yet we seem to accept it as a universal law when we apply it to our economy, as I’m about to explain.
Rent, interest and profit
There are three common processes in an extractive economy which all have the same effect. Wealth is taken from one group of people (often they who ‘hath not’) and given to another (usually those that ‘hath’ already), not for any useful activity, but simply because they already own something. That’s the very definition of unearned income:
-
Rent: Charging someone money for the use of some real or intangible property, over and above what it costs to maintain it
-
Interest: Charging someone for borrowing money, beyond any reasonable risk premium or cover for inflation
-
Profit: Taking dividends or other rewards by virtue of owning stocks and shares, without meaningfully contributing to the business
Let’s look at each of these in more detail:
Rent
Most people are familiar with the concept of rent in the sense of renting a house, apartment or room to live in. In smaller ways we come across it when we rent a car or a bike on holiday. Someone who owns something is charging us money to use it - simple enough.
Economists use ‘rent’ in a wider sense though - it can apply to intellectual property like copyright, patents and trademarks. If you buy a book or a music album, some (often small) amount goes to the writer and musicians. When you buy some pricier medicines, much of that inflated price is a payment to the drug company that holds the patent. If you buy branded trainers that are much the same as “own brand” ones, the difference is primarily the economic rent on the trademark.
Now some of this seems reasonable - I don’t begrudge paying the small business that rents me a bike, because they have to buy it, service it and be there for me to collect and return it. I fully support writers and musicians getting a fair return on their creativity - I’m somewhat involved in that world, too. I understand medicines are hard to create and test, and some of the patent profit from one drug is used to pay for the next. Manufactured demand for branded shoes made in sweatshops, not so much.
Rent on property is trickier. Yes, some private landlords are just ordinary people using it as another way to fill out their pension, and they’re juggling their buy-to-let mortgage (Interest) and maintenance costs trying to make a small profit, and do their best by their tenants. No Blame2. But there are also some very, very rich people for whom housing stock is just an asset, and who definitely don’t get directly involved if the drains get blocked.
So in all these cases, sometimes there’s a reasonable reward for risk-taking, effort and creativity, sometimes it’s just passive accumulation, sometimes it’s extreme rentierism3. It’s largely a question of scale and length of time.
Interest
Compared to the many forms of ‘rent’, interest is pretty simple. Someone who has more money than you do lends you some, and you pay back more than you borrowed. We’ve all done this, with mortgages, overdrafts and credit cards. If we’re lucky, we might also sit on the other side of the fence - we deposit some spare money somewhere and it magically ‘grows’ as if it were a tree, or a child. What’s actually happening is someone else is paying you for the privilege of using your money.
Economists talk about interest in terms of time preference. You could wait and save up for that house, car or TV, and you’d end up paying less overall, but you want it now - often for good reasons.
To a lender (which you are when you receive any interest on savings), interest has four different parts:
- A “Risk premium” - a percentage representing the expected loss (over many deals) of the borrower not paying it back (defaulting). As an ordinary saver in the UK, with FSCS4, that risk is basically nil. For a bank issuing mortgages, the risk is the loss on high-percentage mortgages if they have to repossess, but it’s fairly rare. For a credit card or commercial loan provider, the risk is greater, which is why they try to justify such high rates.
-
An “Inflation premium” - because of inflation, that money will be worth less in a year’s time in terms of real goods, and if you didn’t lend/deposit it, you could buy something that would hold its value, like property. So it’s reasonable to expect the borrower to top it up to maintain the real value. In times of high inflation this can be the majority of the interest rate.
-
A “Management fee” - running a bank or building society costs money, and the primary way they generate income to pay for this is a small slice on the interest rate.
-
The “Risk-free rate” - the actual real-terms benefit you gain just because you already have money - Matthew 25:29 again.
When - like now - interest rates are barely above inflation, the actual return after inflation, or “real” interest rate, is pretty minimal for an ordinary saver (maybe 1-1.5% if you’re lucky). Unless you’re careful and keep switching around you can end up with a less-than-inflation interest rate (negative real interest). So you or I are not going to get rich this way, it’s just a way of saving for the future and avoiding inflation nibbling away at the value of our savings.
Bigger investors, though, have the option of buying government bonds (Treasury Bonds, gilts) which may pay about the same as a building society but are completely risk-free to any amount. Plus they have the interesting property that their value goes up if interest rates fall, and vice versa.
These gilts are where most of the “government borrowing” we hear so much about comes from. It has built up to colossal numbers over time (currently about 3 trillion - million million - pounds)5, and the interest on it is a huge fraction of government spending: around £110 billion a year, or 8% of total government expenditure6. This is about half the cost of the NHS in England (£217bn), and more than the total education budget in England (£97bn)7.
Who holds all this debt and receives all this interest? I’ll come back to this, but it’s around 34% overseas investors (foreign governments and private investors), 29% UK private finance, 20% UK pension funds and insurers, 17% the Bank of England and 0.1% households8.
One way or another, we are collectively paying immense sums to rich people globally, as pure unearned income.
Profit
Conventionally, we think of profit as something that businesses make - most simply by selling stuff for more than it cost to buy it or make it, and more than enough to cover their overheads (wages, rent, …). We rightly get upset when we see businesses like banks, oil companies or supermarkets making massive profits when we are struggling to pay for their products.
On the other hand, if our local plumber or greengrocer makes a profit which pays for their mortgage or heating bill, no-one would reasonably object. Even if they employ a few staff (on fair terms) and make enough to buy a nice house, that’s no more than any of us would want for ourselves - and anyone who has run a small business will understand that some kind of payback for the long hours and risk is reasonable. Again, No Blame.
So what’s the difference? It’s not just a matter of scale, although that tends to focus the mind on the big numbers. The difference is who gets the reward. In the case of big businesses, either publicly traded or privately owned, it’s the shareholders9, most of whom will have nothing to do with running the business day-to-day. They receive benefits simply because they own something - the shares. Once again “to [those] that hath shall be given”.
There’s another mechanism at play in the tech world. Companies often don’t actually make a profit, but the market (= gamblers) believes they will coin it in the future, perhaps by achieving some kind of monopoly (Microsoft, Apple, Google, OpenAI…). So their share price rockets, and the founders and early investors can sell some or all of the company through a stock listing (IPO) or to another, even more overvalued giant. The result is the same, although riskier - by virtue of ownership and on the backs of work by others, they gain riches out of all proportion to their actual effort.
Now you could (and capitalist economists do) argue that these rewards are the fruit of the innovation, risk capital and hard work of the founders and seed investors. The problem is it’s not just their personal innovation and hard work that creates the value, yet they take all of it, and in some famous cases, the scale is obscene. In the case of the seed investors (often ‘venture capitalists’ or private equity funds), they do take a risk, but they spread that risk over so many companies it turns into a fairly reliable unearned income for their participants.
Compounding
This transfer of wealth from poor to rich would be bad enough, but the real kicker is that it compounds. The gains to the rich accumulate so they get richer each year, and so their ‘passive’ income increases, making them richer still the next year, unless they spend it (there’s only so much you can spend). Likewise for those on the losing side, the amount they owe keeps growing each year, unless they manage to pay some of it off.
The charts below show how £1,000 either owned or owed today compounds over 25 years. You can change the real rate of return to capital (rent, interest and profit, minus inflation) with the sliders below the charts. I’ve chosen 5% as the default because it’s about what UK shares and property (price growth plus rent) have each returned since 1900, although it varies a lot from one period to another; cash has returned far less10.
Show the numbers
| Year | Balance in today's money |
|---|---|
| Now | £1,000 |
| Year 1 | £1,050 |
| Year 2 | £1,103 |
| Year 3 | £1,158 |
| Year 4 | £1,216 |
| Year 5 | £1,276 |
| Year 6 | £1,340 |
| Year 7 | £1,407 |
| Year 8 | £1,477 |
| Year 9 | £1,551 |
| Year 10 | £1,629 |
| Year 11 | £1,710 |
| Year 12 | £1,796 |
| Year 13 | £1,886 |
| Year 14 | £1,980 |
| Year 15 | £2,079 |
| Year 16 | £2,183 |
| Year 17 | £2,292 |
| Year 18 | £2,407 |
| Year 19 | £2,527 |
| Year 20 | £2,653 |
| Year 21 | £2,786 |
| Year 22 | £2,925 |
| Year 23 | £3,072 |
| Year 24 | £3,225 |
| Year 25 | £3,386 |
Show the numbers
| Year | Balance in today's money |
|---|---|
| Now | −£1,000 |
| Year 1 | −£1,050 |
| Year 2 | −£1,103 |
| Year 3 | −£1,158 |
| Year 4 | −£1,216 |
| Year 5 | −£1,276 |
| Year 6 | −£1,340 |
| Year 7 | −£1,407 |
| Year 8 | −£1,477 |
| Year 9 | −£1,551 |
| Year 10 | −£1,629 |
| Year 11 | −£1,710 |
| Year 12 | −£1,796 |
| Year 13 | −£1,886 |
| Year 14 | −£1,980 |
| Year 15 | −£2,079 |
| Year 16 | −£2,183 |
| Year 17 | −£2,292 |
| Year 18 | −£2,407 |
| Year 19 | −£2,527 |
| Year 20 | −£2,653 |
| Year 21 | −£2,786 |
| Year 22 | −£2,925 |
| Year 23 | −£3,072 |
| Year 24 | −£3,225 |
| Year 25 | −£3,386 |
Sidebar: An engineer’s view
An engineer from any discipline - audio, electronic, mechanical - will immediately recognise these processes as creating a positive feedback loop, which you really don’t want. That howl from the speakers when the sound engineer messes up? Positive feedback. Your transistors get hot and then melt? Positive feedback. Your bridge shakes itself to pieces? Positive feedback.
They all stem from the same thing - something changes, and the system responds in a way that makes it worse. Without some kind of control, the result is always unstable and usually unpleasant. That’s where we are in economics right now.
Three sides of the same coin
I’ve described Rent, Interest and Profit as three separate things here, but for a very rich person, they are easily interchangeable. Own a lot of property? It’s probably in a holding company, and you can sell shares in that for cash or other shares really easily. Own a lot of shares? You can borrow cash using them as collateral, and you never pay any income tax because you’re technically in debt. Cash-rich? Ask your portfolio manager (you don’t imagine the rich do this themselves, do you?) to shift into utility stocks or gilts.
It all adds up to the same thing - the very foundation of our economy. The extractive part of Capitalism has a whole raft of ways to take money from people with less of it and give it to people who already have more.
Does that seem fair to you?
Footnotes
-
Actually I’m an atheist, but I can still accept that Jesus and his followers had something useful to say. ↩
-
I’m going to come back to this in a later post, but basically, No Blame on the ordinary person trying to lift themselves up. ↩
-
Rentier: an economist’s term (usually negative) for someone who just extracts value without putting any back. ↩
-
Financial Services Compensation Scheme - in the UK, if a bank or building society goes bust, the scheme will pay out up to £120,000 per person per institution. If you’re lucky enough to have more than £120,000 in savings, the usual trick is to split it across lots of different providers. ↩
-
Public sector net debt was provisionally £3,005bn at the end of September 2026, or 94% of GDP (ONS Public sector finances, September 2026). Gilts were 97% of the £2,994bn debt portfolio run by the UK Debt Management Office at the end of June (DMO Quarterly Review, April-June 2026). ↩
-
£108.7bn out of £1,366bn total spending in 2025-26, the last full financial year (OBR Economic and fiscal outlook, October 2026, tables 5.8 and A.7). This is central government debt interest net of the Bank of England’s Asset Purchase Facility (QE). Other official measures for the same year range from £96.9bn (central government gross) to £130.3bn (public sector, including Bank of England transactions) (PESA 2026, tables 1.1 and 5.4). The OBR forecasts £123.9bn, about 8.5% of spending, for 2026-27 - £14.5bn more than it expected in March, mostly because higher inflation raises the cost of index-linked gilts. ↩
-
Departmental budgets (total DEL) for 2025-26: £217.4bn for Health and Social Care, which funds the NHS in England, and £97.3bn for Education (PESA 2026, table 1.9). These departments cover England only, whereas debt interest is UK-wide: across the whole UK, 2025-26 public spending was £257.5bn on health and £125.7bn on education (table 4.2), so debt interest was about 42% and 86% of those respectively. ↩
-
Gilt holdings at market value at the end of March 2026, out of £2,199bn: overseas 33.6%; insurance companies and pension funds 20.2%; Bank of England Asset Purchase Facility 16.6%; households and non-profits 0.1%. “UK private finance” here combines other financial institutions and private non-financial companies (18.6%) with banks and similar monetary financial institutions (10.8%) (DMO Quarterly Review, April-June 2026, using ONS data). ↩
-
Using ‘shareholder’ loosely here - also including commercial bond holders etc. ↩
-
UK returns after inflation, compounded, calculated from the Macrohistory Database behind Jordà et al., The Rate of Return on Everything. 1900-2020: shares 4.9%, government bonds 1.3%, cash 0.5%, property 4.9% (no data for 1940-46). 1950-2020: shares 6.5%, bonds 2.1%, cash 0.9%, property 6.1%. Property includes rent net of running costs, mostly the rent owners save by living in their own home, and is before mortgage interest and tax; price growth alone was 2.3% a year from 1950. ↩